- A rogue called Blenkarn sends Lindsay (P) a letter offering to buy certain goods
- He makes sure to sign his name so that it looks like ‘Blenkiron & Co’ which is a well respected business
- The P sent the goods to the address the Rogue had listed, but he never paid for them and instead sold them to the defendant
- Lindsay called “mistake”!
- The Plaintiff had never intended to deal with Blenkarn, and would not have
- There could never be consensus between the Plaintiff and the rogue, so the Plaintiff’s mistake voided the contract
- Therefore the rogue had no title and as per nemo dat, no right to sell the goods.
- The plaintiff succeeded in an action of conversion
-- Download Cundy v Lindsay (1878) 3 AC 459 as PDF --
Save this case