North Ocean Shipping Co v Hyundai Construction Co Ltd [1979] QB 705

You are here:
< Back
Facts
  • A company enters into an agreement to build a ship for a specified sum in American dollars
  • They had to pay the amount in 5 instalments
  • During this time, the American currency devalues by 10%
  • The company building the ship refuses to continue building until they decide to pay the extra 10%
  • The receiving company give up and pay but later say they were under economic duress
Held
  • Mocatta J: You don’t necessarily have to protest to have a claim in economic duress
  • You don’t have to only recover under very specific guidelines established by English cases, in Australia
  • Compulsion may be economic duress
  • Australian Courts will be very reluctant to enforce a new contract made under economic duress, even when consideration exists
  • However when they were free from duress, they took no action to remedy the unfairness
  • It appears that the owners affirmed the contract and therefore they cannot claim back the 10%

-- Download North Ocean Shipping Co v Hyundai Construction Co Ltd [1979] QB 705 as PDF --


FavoriteLoadingSave this case